There’s a line Tim Howard once put neatly: the truly elite players, the ones wired to compete every time they pull their socks up, can live with a benching if the team is flying. If you’re winning and playing well, they might not like it, but they can rationalise it. The danger comes when you’re rotating, leaving them out, and the team still looks a bit lost.
That, more than any formation board or pressing trigger, is the real “management” side of elite football. You can ask a top player to swallow a couple of games on the sidelines, but only if the decision looks like it’s helping Liverpool. If it isn’t, you’re basically inviting the question: what’s the point?
Winning makes rotation believable
Fans love the idea of keeping everyone fresh. Managers talk about “the squad” and “minutes”. But the dressing room runs on a simpler currency: results. When you’re putting teams away and the attack is humming, a superstar can accept being rested because it feels like part of something that’s working.
And then, crucially, you bring them back in. Not as a favour, but as part of the rhythm that keeps them sharp and hungry. That’s how you stop your best players drifting into cruise control, while still protecting them from being run into the ground.
When it’s going wrong, nobody accepts it
Flip it around and it gets messy quickly. If Liverpool are playing poorly and dropping points, leaving out your top-level leaders isn’t “rotation” anymore, it’s a decision that gets challenged. Not always in public, not always with strops, but the feeling seeps in: why am I watching this when I could change it?
History’s full of examples of huge names who simply didn’t take kindly to losing their spot. Steven Gerrard wasn’t built to watch games pass him by. Other greats have reacted the same way when they felt they were being parked while the team wasn’t improving.
The Salah point: you need him, so manage him
That’s why the Mohamed Salah bit matters. Players at that level don’t need protecting from pressure, they need clarity and purpose. If you’re not selling a player like that, then you’re committing to the hard part: managing his edge.
Truth is, Liverpool need elite players to do elite things across a season. So the job for Arne Slot isn’t just picking a team on a Saturday. It’s keeping the standards high enough that rotation feels like strategy, not like self-sabotage.
Related Articles
About Liverpool News Views
Liverpool News Views offers daily Liverpool coverage including match reaction, transfer analysis, EFL context, tactical breakdowns and opinion-led articles written by supporters for supporters.
