There’s a certain type of transfer debate that always turns into “pay now or wait for the bargain later”. And I get it. Nobody wants to feel like they’ve been done over. But on a player like Marc Guehi, the price needs looking at through Liverpool’s actual needs, not just the neatest version of the deal.
The first point is simple enough: if he ends up at Manchester City now, or disappears to someone else in the summer on a free, are we genuinely confident Liverpool can land someone at that level for £40m? I’m not. In this market, £40m doesn’t stretch the way it used to, especially when you’re talking about a defender who looks ready-made for the modern game.
It’s not just “£40m or nothing”
I don’t really buy the framing that it’s £40m now or “free” later, as if those are the only two outcomes. Players are worth whatever you’re willing to pay at a specific moment, for a specific reason. Timing matters. Squad shape matters. The feel of a season matters.
If Liverpool are in a spot where the margins are tight, then adding the right defender isn’t a luxury. It’s potentially the difference between a season that’s controlled and one that constantly feels like it’s hanging by a thread.
What you’re paying for is stability
The biggest value isn’t even the name on the back. It’s what a defender like that can give you in the round: calmer build-up when teams press us, better coverage in transitions when games get stretched, and fewer moments where midfielders are having to plug gaps that shouldn’t be there.
And that feeds into everything. It helps you manage games. It helps you rotate without the whole structure wobbling. It helps you keep the tempo where you want it rather than where the opposition drags it.
The real risk is letting rivals get stronger
Here’s the part that would sting: if there’s any risk at all that he goes to City now, or gets hoovered up by someone else in the summer, then standing still starts to look like negligence. Not because spending money is always clever, but because losing good options is how you end up overpaying later for someone you don’t even fancy as much.
Truth is, if he signs a four or five-year deal and performs, nobody’s going to be moaning in year three that we could have got him for free. They’ll just be glad we acted when the opportunity was there.
Related Articles
About Liverpool News Views
Liverpool News Views offers daily Liverpool coverage including match reaction, transfer analysis, EFL context, tactical breakdowns and opinion-led articles written by supporters for supporters.
